When faced with two options, take both?

Here's an interesting one. I purchased Elann's Silken Kydd a few days ago, for my holiday party stole. And then I couldn't bear to wait for it to arrive, so I bought the Kidsilk Haze as well. I'm a good ways into the Kidsilk stole... and then I read this interesting blog post from Sable Stasher. It really does sound like both yarns are identical. Hmmm. Two balls of Kidsilk Haze, care of my LYS, cost 30 bucks. Two balls of Silken Kydd cost me 13 dollars, including shipping.

I do love supporting my local yarn shops, and I'm supposed to be destashing anyways- but I have to say it's getting harder for me to justify paying more than twice the price simply to buy local. Maybe once I'm out of credit card debt, I'll be more willing? In the meantime I'm a failed budgeter, having bought essentially the same thing twice. BUT! This means I can make *two* stoles- and the next one will be of a completely different pattern. I wear black shawl things or sweaters just about all the time, so it will hardly go to waste.

I have a great deal of ambivalence about this pricing thing. I will spend a significant amount of money on certain things, due to their quality and workmanship, or because they fit perfectly (always a challenge on my frame), or because it's unique and I know I'll never have the opportunity again. I also will spend extra on things that really do seem to be better off for me and the world at large- I aim to buy local, I try to support independent artisans and especially local ones (or ones from New England, for sentimental reasons). But when faced with identical alternatives, how do you scoff at the option that saves money? Rowan hardly needs my help- and both yarns are imported from Italy. Supporting a LYS is wonderful, but so is supporting one's pocketbook.

What a quandary. I really want to knit with both, to determine how "essentially similar" they are to the hand as well as to the mind. After all, the Kidsilk Haze is a dream to work with- I hope the Silken Kydd is just as soft and delicious.